Missing – one tea mug & car keys

March 24, 2016

“There is nothing more deceptive than an obvious fact.”
― Sir Arthur Conan Doyle,

 

Since starting to write blogs I have been approached by a whole host of “experts” who are offering their consultative skills on just about everything you ever need to know about recruitment.  But what makes them an expert, how do I know what they are telling me is correct? One man tried to evidence his pedigree by the number of people he’s connected with on LinkedIn – my daughter has 500 followers on Instagram but she’s no David Bailey!  I’m noticing more that I am constantly being told what to think and what to say yet I’m not sure I question things enough?

I just watched an advert where a man and a giant tortoise are sat on a sofa, apparently brought together by the faulty magic of a dating site. If he’d used their dating site he’d be sat next to his perfect woman, drinking champagne whilst watching the northern lights from their isolated tropical island (yes I know, geographically that’s not correct but its magic and therefore anything’s possible.  Keep up!).  They claim they can perform such wizardry (or witchery, they are an equal opportunities employer) because their service can match people perfectly.  Really?  Is there a piece of technology that can 100% match two people to the point where they want to be together forever? If their technology did what they claim, I wouldn’t have spent a very long evening in a pub changing seats 4 times with a man who apparently “was my perfect match” (the 4th seat change being to my car seat as I beat a hasty retreat). But I imagine there are lots of people who watch the advert, believe the dream and pay the subscription.

An article on LinkedIn recently claimed that the site was being dumbed down, no longer a professional networking site but becoming another Facebook.  She claimed that inappropriate profile photos (agreed, no one needs to see a half drunk recruiter wearing a jaunty party hat or someone in their bikini looking very pink from the sun), status updates that aren’t work orientated and a lack of ability to type will be the downfall of this networking tool.  Really? Are people that offended by someone who announces the birth of their baby or has achieved a personal goal? As professional people are we not supposed to develop relationships with colleagues, clients, candidates and suppliers?  Nobody develops relationships through just talking about work – “people deal with people” and you only know a person if you have a shared commonality.  One of my Account Manager’s has just got engaged and I couldn’t be more pleased for him, I wouldn’t care if he’d taken out a banner advert on LinkedIn to announce it.  But how many people read that article and took it as gospel, deleting any hint of a personality from their profile?  Who wants to work with a soulless Robot?

And if we get negative feedback do we automatically believe we are in the wrong?  TripAdvisor is full of negative feedback and if you only look at the overall rating you wouldn’t leave your house BUT, if you take the time to read the comments you understand that the rating isn’t a fair assessment of the hotel. Some people will rate a hotel as 1 just because the bathroom didn’t have free body lotion or the hotel couldn’t offer kippers for breakfast – neither of which would be on my list of preferences when I book a hotel room.  So, before I make my final decision of which hotel to stay in I read all the comments and make an informed choice based on my needs, not the needs of a slippery kipper eater.

Our office is approached daily by new job boards, social media sites and aggregators telling us they are the new magicians who are going to be the answer to all our candidate dreams – no giant tortoises on their site, just experienced candidates who match our vacancy perfectly.  Really? Can they deliver anything different to the advertisers we currently use?  Do I then believe what they say and regurgitate it to back to my clients? NO! I don’t believe in magic, if you tell me the grass is green you need to be prepared to dig it up and put a piece on my desk. If you tell me you can bring me candidates I want to see them first.  Every month we trial a range of online advertisers, break most of them but a few survive the test and only then do I believe what I’m told.  And this month’s frog is called Indeed and is looking very likely to become a Prince, so good the advertiser may be added to the Emergency Boost package from next month.

So, you need to question more & believe less.  Break it and see how it goes back together. Talk to people, ask for recommendations and speak to the people who have given testimonials. And only then make YOUR decision.

But don’t take my word for it, who am I?  I spent most of this morning looking for where I’d put my tea mug & found my car keys in the dishwasher (with the missing mug!). And, I have a soft spot for giant tortoises.

– Chelle

    Want updates from Candidate Source?

    If you'd like to be kept up to date with the latest goings on here at Candidate Source, simply fill out the form below.

    Privacy Policy

    I would like receive information on:

    Related

    Media Buying Contract Video

    March 4, 2026

    When you want a longer term relationship with job boards, we’ll work with you to ...

    Pay As You Go Video

    March 4, 2026

    Our Pay As You Go service means you can use the job boards using your ...

    Ad Hoc Services

    March 4, 2026

    You send us the info, we write the ad, place it on all the top ...

    CV Sifting

    February 26, 2026

    Filtering and screening responses is a vital part of the recruitment process – you’re often ...

    Candidate Source Ltd