Remember why the job boards put prices up a few years ago? Because the cost of attracting candidates to a job was, and still is, at a premium & whether a recruiter or direct employer is advertising, the cost of candidate acquisition per vacancy is the same. That’s why they decided to level up the pricing so the difference in price per advert between a recruiter & an employer wasn’t so vast. And all that extra money would be spent on attracting candidates, which would benefit us all.
There would be fewer jobs advertised, but the jobs advertised would be of better quality, which, in turn, would improve the candidate experience. Quality candidates would flock to the job board, and with fewer vacancies, your advert would have less competition, and you’d have more chance of filling your role.
Happy Candidates, Happy Job Board, Happy Recruiters.
But, with the suggested new pricing models, that seems to have been forgotten & now, their new focus is to make themselves look better value for money.
But what do these newly proposed pricing models mean to recruiters & the one thing they need – quality candidates?
Unlimited vacancies (or, as it was referred to the other day, “all you can eat”)
From a Head Office perspective, within a multi-branch company, I understand the attraction of an unlimited package. You know the price upfront, no nasty budget surprises, no branch running out of postings, and a good bit of PR being able to say to the Board, “Our brand will be everywhere” (I know, I was the person who did these deals when she worked for a large agency). But, for the consultants, the job board & the candidates, unlimited vacancy packages are a nightmare.
Unlimited vacancies have no cost per advert, in fact, the more you post, the “cheaper” the advert becomes, and with no associated cost, comes no responsibility. Consultants will be tempted to fire out “a quick advert”, multiple times with different locations “to see what they get”. Gone will be the beautifully crafted advert, with all the information a candidate needs to apply, and the correct information to be seen by relevant candidates & back will be the poor quality advert. Job boards have been telling us for years that fewer vacancies but better quality adverts on their site attract quality candidates, and now what? Candidates are less fussy, will apply for any old job? I don’t think so, if anything, candidates are more selective now than ever before.
So, it follows for “unlimited vacancies” we will be able to read “unlimited, irrelevant candidates” which must be screened by consultants who have better things to do with their time than wade through 100s of unsuitable CVs. And what happens then? Consultants become frustrated by the unsuitable candidates so start writing adverts to screen them out, removing more of the ‘good stuff’ from the advert and alienating even more relevant candidates.
And then the job board gets inundated with poor quality jobs, the quality candidates go elsewhere, the Recruitment Agency moans that they aren’t making as many placements, and the job board offers the unlimited package at a lower price. The job boards have less revenue to spend on marketing, we have fewer candidates coming to the site & when they do, there are more vacancies than ever to wade through and so the spiral into resourcing hell continues.
Pay per started application/pay per application
OK, so you don’t pay anything for someone to read your advert, you only pay when the candidates click on one of the many links that tick the “started application” box or complete the application (submit their CV). If nobody clicks, the advert doesn’t cost you a penny and you’ve lost nothing.
Result. Or is it?
As a consultant, there could be a perception that there is no financial risk – “I can put on as many jobs as I like because I only pay if someone clicks & if a candidate clicks, it’s because they are interested”. And what have we said about no financial risk? No responsibility.
To achieve your application goal, your job could end up on any third-party source in order to generate applications meaning the quality is massively diluted to achieve the job board’s revenue. Mind you, that’s the same for all of the price models.
It’s a budgetary nightmare. The cost of that click can quickly escalate if it’s a popular job in a main town, and you will only find out your cost for that advert, after the event, and by then, it’s too late, the money is spent. There’s nothing to say that those clicks will be from relevant people so you could end up spending an uncontrolled fortune and still get nothing for your money.
Pay on Placement
My biggest issue when talking to recruiters about their advertising spend is that many have no idea what their ROI is from a job board. Although they have CRM systems, the data is only as good as the information that’s put in, and that’s not always the best. Yes, if your ATS is integrated with your CRM you have a greater chance but there are a lot of agencies that don’t.
I know an agency for who most of their candidates on the CRM were classified as “walk-in” because, and this is true, they “walk-in” to the branch to register. By the time they are registered, the consultant doesn’t know where the original application came from and associates them with a registration in the branch.
From that starting point, we think agencies will be proactive in logging all their applications so they can accurately report to a job board how many placements they made, and receive a nice juicy invoice? We’ve spent our recruitment careers dealing with clients who try to wiggle out of paying placement fees because the applicant came from a different source – do the job boards think we haven’t learnt a few avoidance skills along the way?
So, as with the unlimited vacancy package, the job boards are inundated with vacancies, (“because we only pay on placement so advertise everything”), the advert quality is poor, the candidates get fed up….. you know the rest
Now, the job board has less to spend on attracting candidates, so the rest of us get fewer candidates, or our price goes up, and we are back to square one.
Pay per advert
It’s a classic, but it’s a classic for many reasons:
But, after all is said and done, the job boards are missing the point. Nobody actually cares how we are charged, or, what we are charged, we just need quality candidates. If I said to my clients, for every £1 you spend you’ll get £20 back, they’d take that deal.
By changing the price structure they are hoping to create a distraction – if you feel you are getting value for money, that you have “done a deal” you won’t focus on the fact that you don’t have candidates.
The job boards need to stop focusing on generating revenue by changing the name of their pricing and focus on what we will happily pay for – quality candidates. Tell us how you spend our money, and what you are doing differently to create candidate flow, – then the revenue will look after itself. LinkedIn charges a fortune, but people pay it because guess what? It generates candidates and that’s all the job boards should be focusing on.
Account Managers should manage our accounts, rather than just ringing us once a year to renew our contract, focus on developing our skills. Some people don’t want to watch a video, they want a human to talk them through using the site. Ring us once in a while to say “I’ve just had a look at your jobs advertised, have you got 5 mins for me to talk you through how you could improve it?”.
Because, at the end of the day, we are happy to make the investment – WE JUST NEED CANDIDATES.
If you'd like to be kept up-to-date with the latest hints, tips and goings-on in the wonderful world of recruitment sign up to our mailing list today.
Don't forget, you can sign up to receive the latest updates and news from us here. Get Updates
Thanks for choosing the receive email updates from us!
Don't forget to confirm your email address, else you won't receive our updates.
Please check your junk/spam folder if you can't see the confirmation email from us.
Thanks,
Frank!